Bad Month for Sandy Hook Truthers in Palm Beach, Florida: (1) James Tracy v FAU dismissed and (2) indictment in U.S. v. Lucy Richards

1st Amendment

In unrelated court proceedings in West Palm Beach, Florida, two Sandy Hook Truthers suffered losses resulting in a dismissal and indictment, respectively.  A university professor who writes blog posts denying the Sandy Hook shooting received a sternly-worded Order of Dismissal which gutted several of his claims while permitting his lawyers a chance to re-write the others.  Separately, a woman was indicted for making bizarre threats via phone and internet to the father of one of the Sandy Hook victims.

James Tracy is a former professor at Florida Atlantic University (FAU) who was fired from his tenured teaching position at the university located in Boca Raton, Florida.  He claims it was because of his ardent belief that the Sandy Hook massacre never happened.  His insightful comments rants on the topic populate his blog, Memory Hole (warning: Google Chrome blocked the site as infected with a trojan horse so we are not linking).

In April 2015, Tracy filed a lengthy lawsuit in federal court claiming that his First Amendment right was violated.  Our first post on the topic, with the links to the court documents, is here.  The Defendants filed their motions to dismiss, which we covered in June 2016, here.

On December 15, 2016, Judge Robin Rosenberg dismissed with prejudice a number of claims and dismissed without prejudice the remaining counts, permitting counsel the chance to re-write those portions.  Her order is here.  Specifically, the individual defendants appear to have largely won this first round with a number of claims dismissed with prejudice however the question whether he was fired for blogging remained a viable action.  A claim for denial of due process was also dismissed.

An Amended Complaint is due to be filed on December 28, 2016.  We’ll report then.  Meanwhile, the court also ordered discovery to proceed.

Separately, in United States of America v. Lucy Richards, a woman allegedly left threatening phone messages for the father of one of the Sandy Hook victims.  She does not appear to reference Sandy Hook directly in the chilling calls but stated, “death is coming to you real soon and there’s nothing you can do about it” and wrote (on social media), “LOOK BEHIND YOU IT IS DEATH.”

The indictment in US v. Lucy Richards is here.  We cannot verify the accuracy but you can hear the alleged voicemails here.

The Tampa Bay Times had some good coverage of the arrest and background, here.

The Sandy Hook shooting, in which 20 children and 6 adults were shot, occurred four years ago on December 14, 2012.

Photo credit: SandyHookAnalysis.blogspot

1st Amendment
The First Amendment and the Hurdles to Obtain an Injunction in Florida for Social Media Cyberstalking (Derek Warren Logue v. Lauren Frances Book)

A Florida trial court entered an injunction for stalking against the appellant for, among other things, posting a picture of the appellee’s house with her address, a song video with obscene title and lyrics, and a cartoon depicting the appellee with an obscene reference. The appellant filed an appeal, claiming …

1st Amendment
Three Steps to Understanding Why Government Officials Cannot Block Users on Social Media (Knight First Amendment Institute et al. v. Donald J. Trump et al.)

There is some confusion about the recent Second Circuit opinion as to how, on a private social media platform, a government official, using a personal account, cannot block other users. The following three step process should lead just about everyone to understand the outcome. The case is Knight First Amendment …

1st Amendment
“Valid Grounds for Employment Action” Deemed Not Enough for Stalking Injunction under F.S. 784.048 (Klenk v. Ransom)

Florida’s First District Court of Appeal held today that a respondent’s behavior may be enough for an “employment action” (presumably, for termination due to sexual harassment) but, in this case, was not enough for the “exacting standard” for an injunction against stalking under Florida Statute 748.048. The case is Joseph …