U.S. v. Elonis — U.S. Supreme Court’s Facebook Case

SCOTUS

A former amusement park employee’s Facebook posts may prove wrong most federal courts or will clearly carve out a rare First Amendment exception.Anthony_Elonis_Wide

The case of U.S. v. Elonis focuses on whether statements, often phrased as rap music, could be a “true threat” which would make it a crime if a reasonable person were to perceive a threat.

This case is unusual, not because it is the first Facebook case to reach the Supreme Court, but because it touches upon “new” mediums of expression: rap and online communications, where the tone and content can be edgy and context may not always be as clear.

Dive into this (quite detailed) legal issue with “The US Supreme Court’s ‘Facebook Case'” from the March 2015 Palm Beach Bar Bulletin, here.

Then check out the Third District opinion (here) and the briefs (here).

For the truly brave, check out the confusing oral argument, here.

And, for a slightly different twist, read the December 2014 Bell v. Itawamba opinion, here.

1st Amendment
The First Amendment and the Hurdles to Obtain an Injunction in Florida for Social Media Cyberstalking (Derek Warren Logue v. Lauren Frances Book)

A Florida trial court entered an injunction for stalking against the appellant for, among other things, posting a picture of the appellee’s house with her address, a song video with obscene title and lyrics, and a cartoon depicting the appellee with an obscene reference. The appellant filed an appeal, claiming …

1st Amendment
Three Steps to Understanding Why Government Officials Cannot Block Users on Social Media (Knight First Amendment Institute et al. v. Donald J. Trump et al.)

There is some confusion about the recent Second Circuit opinion as to how, on a private social media platform, a government official, using a personal account, cannot block other users. The following three step process should lead just about everyone to understand the outcome. The case is Knight First Amendment …

Internet
When You See People Trying to Sue a Social Media Platform Because Their Account Was Suspended, It’s a Stunt (lessons of the CDA & Brittain v. Twitter)

A number of politicians, activists, and others who feel aggrieved after their Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and/or YouTube content has been removed or their accounts suspended have taken to the courts to sue the social media platforms with claims that they are being singled out, muzzled, or their free speech is …