What is Bitcoin: Currency, Property or Tulips?

A strange title to an article, I know.  But it will make sense at the end:Bitcoin

Governments around the world are struggling to define, and therefore regulate or ban, virtual currency such as bitcoin.  Here in the U.S., various federal agencies have differing conclusions.  So do various states.

Meanwhile, in the press, bitcoin is incorrectly labeled as an anonymous way to transmit money (it isn’t — law enforcement appears to have no problem tracking bitcoin funds) and it is unfairly associated with alleged criminal activity.  Thus, even the judicial system is making efforts to define bitcoin under various statutes.

This article, What is Bitcoin: Currency, Property or… Tulips?, from the Palm Beach Bar Association, discusses how various federal and states agencies and courts have defined bitcoin.  The reference to tulips comes from the Netherlands — there, in an attempt to define bitcoin, they compared it to their well-known consumer export, tulips!

Of note, the “verdict” comments are my conclusions, often, and not necessarily the final word from the government agencies or courts unless indicated.  Expect changes as we go forward.

Palm Beach
Palm Beach Bitcoin Case Heats Up With Plaintiff Deposition, Discovery Memo, and Hearing this Week (Est. of David Kleiman v. Craig Wright)

We have been following the bitcoin lawsuit pending down the street at the federal courthouse in West Palm Beach between the Estate of David Kleiman and W&K Defense Research, LLC, on the one hand, and Craig Wright, on the other. Bitcoin enthusiasts believe that Kleiman and/or Wright may either be …

A Lot of Lawyers Claim That They Accept Bitcoin… But Are They Doing It Wrong?

A lawyers’ ethics committee appointed by the Nebraska Supreme Court issued an opinion regarding whether lawyers in that state could receive payments in bitcoin; receive payments from third parties in bitcoin; and/or hold bitcoin for their clients.  This applies to any digital currency.  The committee was clearly well-informed and wrote …

Virtual Currency
Federal Court Allows Bitcoin Investor Suit to Proceed

A federal court judge in New Jersey entered an order today allowing a civil suit involving Bitcoin investments to proceed.  The Court ruled that it had jurisdiction over the case based upon the pleadings regarding diversity of the parties and the value of the case exceeding $70,000.   In fact, …