What is a “Trade Secret” in Florida Discovery? (the existence of free cable tv, apparently)

What’s a “trade secret” for discovery objections and what are the steps for trial court review?

In Bright House Networks, LLC v. Albert C. Cassidy et al. (Florida Second District, Jan. 10, 2014), we learn that at least one cable TV provider apparently provides free service to “a significant number of recipients.”  Moreover, the list of those customers was claimed to be a trade secret.

How does a party raise a trade secret objection?  And what steps are required to overcome it?

In Bright House, the Second DCA held that referencing “trade secrets, confidential, and/or proprietary business information” was sufficient language to preserve the issue.

Consistent with Florida Statutes 90.506 (privilege against disclosure of trade secrets), a  trial court should take the following steps:

1.  Determine if the requested information is a “trade secret” per Florida Statute 688.002(4).  This is usually done via an in camera inspection.  A customer list can be a trade secret.  Here, the Second DCA admitted that an in camera inspection of a list of names/addresses might not be helpful.  That said, a hearing (and evidence) might be needed to determine whether the compilation of information is confidential and that the company acquired it through the pursuit of its business strategy and course of confidential negotiations.

2.  Determine if the requesting party has shown reasonable necessity.  This includes limiting production to items necessary for a court to determine contested issues.

3.  Order safeguards, as needed.

 

E-discovery
Christopher Hopkins Discusses Social Media Discovery in 2018 at Palm Beach Bar Association

Special thanks to the Palm Beach Bar Association for inviting me to speak at the CLE, “How to Get Your Claim Move-In Ready for Trial.” Space is still available and you can sign up here. My small portion of the event was to discuss Florida social media discovery as well …

E-discovery
NBI CLE: Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Email, and Smartphone Evidence (Florida)

Special thanks to National Business Institute (NBI) for hosting this 2-day CLE seminar in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. You can find the seminar information (and download the audio) here. My topics included: Apps and Emerging Technology You Must Know Preserving Electronic Evidence and Avoiding Spoliation Social Media Cases Metadata Made Simple …

Arbitration Mediation
Florida Dispute Resolution Conference 2018: Christopher Hopkins Discusses ESI/E-Discovery for Mediators AND Cyber Security and Data Breach for Mediators

Thanks to the Florida Dispute Resolution Conference for inviting me to speak at the 2018 conference. Topics covered: 25 ESI and E-Discovery Terms for Mediators in 75 minutes and Cybersecurity and Data Breach for Mediators. You can download the presentations here and here. If you would like CME points, you …